The Cloudiness in Coffee and Black Tea After Cooling: Causes, Structural Differences, and Flavor Impact

Contents:

1. Similarities
2. Differences
3. Conclusion

When coffee cools, it often becomes cloudy—a phenomenon similar in appearance to the “tea cream” effect in black tea but driven by different underlying causes. The tea cream effect, also known as “chill haze,” usually occurs when black tea cools. It results from a polymerization reaction between theaflavins and caffeine, forming fine nano-sized particles that give the tea a hazy, amber appearance. In coffee, however, cloudiness primarily stems from suspended particles, oil separation, and acid precipitation. As coffee cools, these components form larger particles or aggregates, reducing its clarity. Though both are triggered by temperature-induced polymerization, the different components and physical properties in each lead to distinct cloudiness effects and flavor changes.

Similarities

Temperature Changes Triggering Polymerization

Tea Cream in Black Tea: The tea cream (or “chill haze”) forms in black tea as it cools when theaflavins and caffeine combine to create nano-sized polymer structures. These particles disperse in the tea, making it appear cloudy and orange-brown, especially during rapid cooling or iced tea preparation.

Cloudiness in Coffee: In coffee, the cloudiness after cooling is due to suspended particles, oil separation, and acid precipitation. As the temperature drops, these substances form larger particles or aggregates, causing the coffee to lose its original clarity.

Primarily Caused by Polyphenols and Colloidal Structures

The tea cream in black tea forms through the polymerization of theaflavins, polyphenols, and caffeine, while in coffee, polyphenols, proteins, and oils tend to aggregate or separate upon cooling, leading to cloudiness. Both changes involve shifts in colloidal structures, disrupting uniformity and increasing light scattering, resulting in a cloudy appearance.

Reversible Phenomenon

When the tea cream disappears (as the tea warms), the liquid becomes clear again as the nano-particles dissolve or disperse once more.

Similarly, the cloudy particles in coffee may dissolve upon reheating, partially restoring clarity. However, the effect is usually less pronounced due to oil separation and suspended particles, which are less likely to fully re-dissolve.

Differences

Different Main Components

The main contributors to tea cream are theaflavins and caffeine, which aggregate at low temperatures to create nano-structures that cause opacity in tea. This effect is most noticeable in black teas and some high-concentration tea brews.

Coffee cloudiness primarily involves suspended particles (like fine grounds), oils, and acidic compounds, which aggregate and separate with temperature changes and oxidation.

Size and Structure of Cloudy Particles Differ

The particles in tea cream are smaller (nano-sized) and more stable, making it easier for them to disperse or disappear upon reheating.

Coffee’s cloudy substances are generally larger (micro-sized), especially oil or protein aggregates. These particles are more difficult to disperse with temperature changes, so coffee cloudiness may not fully revert to its original clear state.

Flavor Impact

The formation of tea cream can enhance the flavor, making the tea thicker and more full-bodied. Some tea enthusiasts even prefer teas that develop tea cream upon cooling.

Coffee cloudiness, however, often brings a heavier flavor profile, with oil and particle separation sometimes adding bitterness or astringency, which is generally less desirable.

Conclusion

In summary, while the cloudiness in cooled coffee and the tea cream effect in black tea appear similar, their mechanisms and contributing factors are distinctly different. The tea cream in black tea arises from nano-structures formed by polyphenols and caffeine, often appreciated as a unique flavor feature of black tea. In coffee, cloudiness results more from suspended particles, oil separation, and oxidation, typically seen as a sign of quality decline. Understanding these phenomena can help us adjust brewing parameters to optimize flavor and maintain clarity. Tea cream has become a preferred characteristic among tea drinkers, while coffee cloudiness can be minimized through proper filtration and brewing techniques to enhance the drinking experience.

│Further reading: Why Coffee Becomes Cloudy as It Cools and How to Address It

Recommended Products:

  ​​

〔Justin Coffee〕

✔ High-Altitude Estate Coffee Beans ✔Freshly Roasted Coffee Bean Specialty Store  ✔Million-Dollar Sorting Machine for Flawless Beans
✔ CQI international coffee quality appraiser quality control
✔ State-of-the-art, Million-dollar Coffee Bean Sorting Machine Removes Defective Beans

5 Commitments to Premium Coffee, Delivering the Best Quality to You!

We welcome your communication.